Talk:Ave Maria (Bonnie Barrows)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Not 3 voices. Needs tenor for last two bars. So SATB ? Unless contributor rewrites those two bars.

Marghek 10:04, 10 February 2011 (CST)

Declaring the piece as 3 voices (SAB) is ok (imho), although voices are splittet in the last (two) bars. But bar 18 is unclear. I've edited the whole piece, making it one page, changing hyphenation for mulieribus and peccatoribus, changing B.18 (also text for soprano above staff) and changing double accidentials. I'm new to CPDL and don't know how to upload and make it available (PDF,Audio,Sibelius6). Hilmar Böhm. --Hilix 04:45, 11 February 2011 (CST)

Reply by: Vaarky 11:24, 6 March 2011 (CST)


There is debate about how to indicate pieces that are largely 3 part but require 4 voices for a very brief portion of the piece. Personally, I prefer to see such pieces classified as 4-part because I think people searching for SAB may be looking for pieces that they can do if they only have one bass in their choir or basses who can't handle divisi. In any case, I've updated the score description page to indicate the brief divisi but left it 3 part at this point.

In case you haven't already solved the iesue of replacing the score with a newly edited version, first upload a replacement score by using the Upload File link on the left hand side. Then either edit the score page to replace the old link for the file, or e-mail addscore At sign.png if you need help.