Talk:Vola il tempo e sa manchare (Juan Escribano): Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
I propose moving this page to 'Vola il tempe e sa manchare (Juan Escribano)'. According to RISM they are the same person, and Escribano already has a composer page on CPDL. [[User:GeoffG|GeoffG]] ([[User talk:GeoffG|talk]]) 23:55, 15 September 2020 (UTC) | I propose moving this page to 'Vola il tempe e sa manchare (Juan Escribano)'. According to RISM they are the same person, and Escribano already has a composer page on CPDL. [[User:GeoffG|GeoffG]] ([[User talk:GeoffG|talk]]) 23:55, 15 September 2020 (UTC) | ||
I actually second this, either by changing the works page to 'Vola il tempo e sa manchere (Juan Escribano)' or to 'Vola il tempo e sa manchere (Ioannes Scrivano/Juan Escribano)'. In the later chase, the composer's page should also be revised. I was in a hurry when posting the first version of this edition and was not aware of the identification in RISM. (Sorry I strive to be accurate in the background work). I have updated the edition PDF and source file giving the composer as Ioannes Scrivano (Juan Escribano). (I would actually prefer works- and composer-page giving both the name in its Spanish form and in the Italian form of the name as that is the one indicated in the source. | :I actually second this, either by changing the works page to 'Vola il tempo e sa manchere (Juan Escribano)' or to 'Vola il tempo e sa manchere (Ioannes Scrivano/Juan Escribano)'. In the later chase, the composer's page should also be revised. I was in a hurry when posting the first version of this edition and was not aware of the identification in RISM. (Sorry I strive to be accurate in the background work). I have updated the edition PDF and source file giving the composer as Ioannes Scrivano (Juan Escribano). (I would actually prefer works- and composer-page giving both the name in its Spanish form and in the Italian form of the name as that is the one indicated in the source. | ||
I will postpone the posting of an edition of the second work by Escribano/Scrivano in Canzoni Nove and wait for these changes. Andreas [[user:Stenand|Stenand]] | :I will postpone the posting of an edition of the second work by Escribano/Scrivano in Canzoni Nove and wait for these changes. Andreas [[user:Stenand|Stenand]] | ||
::I've renamed the work page as you see. We never kept two names in the title of one composer page. So I've used a redirection from the other composer name to this one. I hope you agree. [[User:Claude T|Claude]] ([[User talk:Claude T|talk]]) 20:16, 17 September 2020 (UTC) |
Latest revision as of 20:17, 17 September 2020
I propose moving this page to 'Vola il tempe e sa manchare (Juan Escribano)'. According to RISM they are the same person, and Escribano already has a composer page on CPDL. GeoffG (talk) 23:55, 15 September 2020 (UTC)
- I actually second this, either by changing the works page to 'Vola il tempo e sa manchere (Juan Escribano)' or to 'Vola il tempo e sa manchere (Ioannes Scrivano/Juan Escribano)'. In the later chase, the composer's page should also be revised. I was in a hurry when posting the first version of this edition and was not aware of the identification in RISM. (Sorry I strive to be accurate in the background work). I have updated the edition PDF and source file giving the composer as Ioannes Scrivano (Juan Escribano). (I would actually prefer works- and composer-page giving both the name in its Spanish form and in the Italian form of the name as that is the one indicated in the source.
- I will postpone the posting of an edition of the second work by Escribano/Scrivano in Canzoni Nove and wait for these changes. Andreas Stenand