Difference between revisions of "Talk:Missa super Ut re mi fa sol la octavi toni (Blasius Ammon)"

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "This mass appears to be an inferior version (e.g. missing Osanna, etc.) of Orlando di Lasso's Missa Jäger (Missa octavi toni}. Donfrid (1628 compiler) has both misattributed...")
 
 
Line 1: Line 1:
This mass appears to be an inferior version (e.g. missing Osanna, etc.) of Orlando di Lasso's Missa Jäger (Missa octavi toni}. Donfrid (1628 compiler) has both misattributed and mistitled his source. It is not worth merging this piece with that, which already has 5+ versions on CPDL. I suggest either deleting this item or leaving it as the evidencing of a specious piece attributed to Amon.~~
+
This mass appears to be an inferior version (e.g. missing Osanna, etc.) of Orlando di Lasso's Missa Jäger (Missa octavi toni}. Donfrid (1628 compiler) has both misattributed and mistitled his source. It is not worth merging this piece with that, which already has 5+ versions on CPDL. I suggest either deleting this item or leaving it as the evidencing of a specious piece attributed to Amon.[[User:Cjshawcj|Cjshawcj]] ([[User talk:Cjshawcj|talk]]) 11:23, 9 December 2020 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 11:24, 9 December 2020

This mass appears to be an inferior version (e.g. missing Osanna, etc.) of Orlando di Lasso's Missa Jäger (Missa octavi toni}. Donfrid (1628 compiler) has both misattributed and mistitled his source. It is not worth merging this piece with that, which already has 5+ versions on CPDL. I suggest either deleting this item or leaving it as the evidencing of a specious piece attributed to Amon.Cjshawcj (talk) 11:23, 9 December 2020 (UTC)