Talk:Bozrah (James P. Carrell)

From ChoralWiki
Revision as of 16:53, 28 March 2021 by Claude T (talk | contribs) (Claude T a déplacé la page Talk:Bozrah (Anonymous) vers Talk:Bozrah (Joseph Knapicius): per "First published:"? see Talk:Bozrah (Anonymous))
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Page name

There are several ways a hymn page could be handled:

  1. Who is this that comes from far (BOZRAH) (Anonymous)
  2. Bozrah (Anonymous), both with First published: 1835 in Southern Harmony, no. 39
  3. Who is this that comes from far (Joseph Knapicius)
  4. Bozrah (Joseph Knapicius), with First published: 2021

For the Southern Harmony User:Barry Johnston has been consistent in using tune names in sentence case (Detroit (William Bradshaw)) and "anon" (Redeeming Grace (Anonymous)) instead of first line and "trad." (O little town of Bethlehem (Traditional)). Examples of pages that bear arrangers' names are at Veni,_veni_Emmanuel_(O_come,_O_come_Emmanuel)_(Traditional)#Other_arrangements. CPDL #63421 might go either way, but First published: 2021 suggests no.4. Richard Mix (talk) 23:33, 10 March 2021 (UTC)