Difference between revisions of "Talk:Benedicam Dominum a 12 (Andrea Gabrieli)"

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Added discrepancy in m. 62)
m (my edition exists now.)
 
Line 12: Line 12:
  
 
Additionally, I disagree with the editorial lyrics in m. 13-15. There is only set of ij markings in each part, which would indicate one text repetition of the entire previous phrase, not two repetitions.
 
Additionally, I disagree with the editorial lyrics in m. 13-15. There is only set of ij markings in each part, which would indicate one text repetition of the entire previous phrase, not two repetitions.
 
I hope to have these fixed in an upcoming edition. Please contact me if you need it urgently.
 
 
[[User:Ace214|Jon Arnold]] ([[User talk:Ace214|talk]]) 23:35, 13 May 2020 (UTC)
 
[[User:Ace214|Jon Arnold]] ([[User talk:Ace214|talk]]) 23:35, 13 May 2020 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 02:01, 17 January 2021

Score #23983 by Lewis Jones has the following discrepancies with the source:

  • m. 21, quintus: last note should be G
  • m. 26-27, duodecima should start a half note later and end with a half note instead of a whole note
  • m. 27-28, decima should start a half note later
  • m. 62, septima: F-sharp should be notated as ficta as it is not found in the original
  • m. 65, duodecima should start a half note later on the & of beat 3
  • m. 67-68, decima, duodecima and undecima are missing editorial brackets around lyrics
  • m. 67-68, bassus is missing a phrase: r2 d'2 bes4 2 a4 bes4. 8 f2 r1
  • m. 83, altus is missing editorial brackets around lyrics
  • m. 84-end, altus should have whole rest in 84, then half whole half | breve long (the long will line up with the one in the octava part)
  • m. 84-85, septima part is missing editorial brackets around lyrics

Additionally, I disagree with the editorial lyrics in m. 13-15. There is only set of ij markings in each part, which would indicate one text repetition of the entire previous phrase, not two repetitions. Jon Arnold (talk) 23:35, 13 May 2020 (UTC)