Category talk:Incomplete editions: Difference between revisions
Richard Mix (talk | contribs) (see also...) |
Richard Mix (talk | contribs) m (see also...) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
=='Editions'?== | =='Editions'?== | ||
There's some possible ambiguity between "incompletely edited works" such as [[Scenes from the Saga of King Olaf, Op. 30 (Edward Elgar)]] and works that have been completed by several editors, each of whose editions are 'incomplete' by themselves. It does seem to me reasonable that [[As torrents in summer (Edward Elgar)]] (or any excerpt that has a ''Larger work'' field in the general information) does not have the <nowiki>{{IncompleteWork}}</nowiki> tag, but I think it might be very useful to have a category that identifies gaps such as [[Cantata BWV 7 - Christ unser Herr zum Jordan kam (Johann Sebastian Bach)]] while excluding [[Cantata BWV 4 - Christ lag in Todesbanden (Johann Sebastian Bach)]]. | There's some possible ambiguity between "incompletely edited works" such as [[Scenes from the Saga of King Olaf, Op. 30 (Edward Elgar)]] and works that have been completed by several editors, each of whose editions are 'incomplete' by themselves. It does seem to me reasonable that [[As torrents in summer (Edward Elgar)]] (or any excerpt that has a '''Larger work''' field in the general information) does not have the <nowiki>{{IncompleteWork}}</nowiki> tag, but I think it might be very useful to have a category that identifies gaps such as [[Cantata BWV 7 - Christ unser Herr zum Jordan kam (Johann Sebastian Bach)]] while excluding [[Cantata BWV 4 - Christ lag in Todesbanden (Johann Sebastian Bach)]]. | ||
So, do we need a separate [[:Category:Incompletely edited works]], or shall the lead here be modified? [[User:Richard Mix|Richard Mix]] 19:08, 20 June 2012 (CDT) | So, do we need a separate [[:Category:Incompletely edited works]], or shall the lead here be modified? [[User:Richard Mix|Richard Mix]] 19:08, 20 June 2012 (CDT) | ||
(See also [[Template talk:IncompleteEdition]]) | (See also [[Template talk:IncompleteEdition]]) | ||
Latest revision as of 01:38, 21 June 2012
'Editions'?
There's some possible ambiguity between "incompletely edited works" such as Scenes from the Saga of King Olaf, Op. 30 (Edward Elgar) and works that have been completed by several editors, each of whose editions are 'incomplete' by themselves. It does seem to me reasonable that As torrents in summer (Edward Elgar) (or any excerpt that has a Larger work field in the general information) does not have the {{IncompleteWork}} tag, but I think it might be very useful to have a category that identifies gaps such as Cantata BWV 7 - Christ unser Herr zum Jordan kam (Johann Sebastian Bach) while excluding Cantata BWV 4 - Christ lag in Todesbanden (Johann Sebastian Bach).
So, do we need a separate Category:Incompletely edited works, or shall the lead here be modified? Richard Mix 19:08, 20 June 2012 (CDT)
(See also Template talk:IncompleteEdition)