Difference between revisions of "Category talk:Franco-Flemish composers"

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(To me the criterion for whether a composer is South Netherlandish or Franco-Flemish is not clear...)
 
(agree with Wursten and suggest merging this category with Franco-Flemish (except Obrecht - Dutch))
Line 1: Line 1:
 
To me the criterion for whether a composer is South Netherlandish or Franco-Flemish is not clear...
 
To me the criterion for whether a composer is South Netherlandish or Franco-Flemish is not clear...
 
Shouldn't these categories be united ?? --[[User:Wursten|Wursten]] 07:06, 30 December 2005 (PST)
 
Shouldn't these categories be united ?? --[[User:Wursten|Wursten]] 07:06, 30 December 2005 (PST)
 +
 +
:I agree, and I would hope that we defer to the Wikipedia designations where they are present, as these are overseen by [[User:Antandrus|Antandrus]] an Administrator at Wikipedia, a Ph.D. in Music, and an expert on early music whose opinion I respect greatly.  In particular, all of the composers in the South Netherlandish except for Obrecht are listed at Wikipedia as being Franco-Flemish.  Obrecht is listed as Dutch.  I think we should merge the other composers with Franco-Flemish and Obrect with Dutch. [[User:CHGiffen|ChuckGiffen]] 14:40 CST, 30 December 2005

Revision as of 20:47, 30 December 2005

To me the criterion for whether a composer is South Netherlandish or Franco-Flemish is not clear... Shouldn't these categories be united ?? --Wursten 07:06, 30 December 2005 (PST)

I agree, and I would hope that we defer to the Wikipedia designations where they are present, as these are overseen by Antandrus an Administrator at Wikipedia, a Ph.D. in Music, and an expert on early music whose opinion I respect greatly. In particular, all of the composers in the South Netherlandish except for Obrecht are listed at Wikipedia as being Franco-Flemish. Obrecht is listed as Dutch. I think we should merge the other composers with Franco-Flemish and Obrect with Dutch. ChuckGiffen 14:40 CST, 30 December 2005