Talk:A new commandment (Thomas Tallis)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Edition #06947 has several errors:

  • Odd markings in the reduction like the A# in m.15 and E# and E-natural in m.21. Somehow these were converted from naturals to sharps. Also occurs in m. 38 and 44.
  • Several figures are missing eighth note beams in the vocal parts but are correct in the reduction: Bass and Tenor in m. 21 (Bass is also wrong in reduction), Alto and Tenor in m. 24, Alto in m. 30, Bass in m. 33 (also wrong in reduction),
  • In m. 32, the alto part is missing a D-natural.
  • Text is compressed in m. 23

Jon Arnold (talk) 00:50, 17 March 2019 (UTC)

Edition #18172 has the following errors:

  • mm. 34 and 37, Bass A-flat misspelled as G-sharp in part and reduction
  • similarly, in m. 48 Bass E-flat misspelled as D-sharp.

Thomascantor (talk) 13:57, 10 May 2022 (UTC)