Archived talk:Katherine Knecht

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Delete suggested

This page does not seem to host any free scores or useful biographical information. There are just links to publishers' websites. I suggest delete or improve substantially to include bio info. -- Bobnotts 04:06, 21 February 2007 (PST)

I would keep this page, as Ms. Knecht used to have several items on CPDL, but withdrew them to put them on her own website. I would submit that the page should remain about like it is, for the benefit of users who may have downloaded one of the earlier editions, as an explantion if they should happen to return to get it again, why the editions cannot be found on CPDL, and where it might be sourced. Noel Stoutenburg 1352 GMT 21 February, 2007.
Further to the above, the one work (Come thou afflicted (Katherine Knecht)) listed on the composer page now appears to be a dead link, as both this and the composer's home page [1] redirect to [2], which states 'This Account Has Been Suspended' - suggest deleting the pages Katherine Knecht and Come thou afflicted (Katherine Knecht) from CPDL as they now no longer provide either hosted editions or useful links to sources elsewhere? Cydonia 17:28, 19 January 2011 (CST)